Thursday, October 13, 2011

Spaces to study or spaces on shelves?

by puddy77 on Flickr 


I moved to 
Read this post at

5 comments:

  1. Thanks Lane for the link to KUAL. Just one point of clarification about Thorin. She made her comments at a 2009 EDUCAUSE conference - during a debate about the future of the print book in research libraries. So it was more to a peer group than administrator types. What folks did not get, I believe, is that in one of these library issue debates, the goal is to greatly exaggerate the issues so as to completely polarize them. So it's either no book or all books - and Thorin got the no books side of the debate - which came back to haunt her at Syracuse a few weeks later when she actually was having books moved to a remote storage site - not getting rid of all the books - but faculty still freaked on that. Good job of putting together these three articles to point to a trend to which we need to pay attention.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Steven. I didn't know the full context of the Thorin quote and the article implies that she was addressing DU administrators, though it is a bit ambiguous.

    In any event, it isn't the "no books" position that bothers me; libraries can exist quite well without printed books. I think that there are plenty of good reasons to discard print books. Making space for an espresso bar just isn't one of them. It's a trend that may not be dominant in practice, but it's a trend all the same.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your closing example sounds more like a caricature than an extrapolation. Wouldn't any collaborative-space-inhabiting reference librarian worth his or her salt say, "Let's walk over to this media station and look for those articles together. Oh, it's a group project? Great! Who wants to drive?"

    ReplyDelete
  4. Marianne: It's actually more like hysterical hyperbole and it's purely rhetorical.

    Of course any reference librarian worth any amount of salt is going to offer assistance where it's needed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sorry if that criticism came out of nowhere. I was just completely engaged with your essay (and enjoying it) up until the hollow THUD of your hyperbolous example. I realize it was pure rhetoric, but I still expected a more on-target illustration. The rest of that paragraph is so *good*.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.